I am all for table talk. But it has to be relevant and appropriate.
The line gets crossed when one player criticizes another’s play or style.
I normally do not get involved with the talk unless someone needs help defending themselves.
In a tournament last week, I am in seat 4 and sitting directly across from seat 1 due to us being eleven handed.
A very young gun was in seat 5. He was nervous as hell. Under the table, both legs were shaking anytime he was in a hand.
Seat 1 was a 40-something man with sunglasses. He was a classic calling station that thought A-K was the nuts no matter what was on the board.
Me and seat 1 were in a hand before things got reckless.
I had Q-Q and raised like I had aces.
He calls.
The flop comes K-9-3 rainbow.
He checks.
I bet half the pot.
He min raises me.
“You have Ace King,” I say to him.
He stares me down and says, “It is a good time to have Ace King, isn’t it?”
I thought he was cocky and arrogant. I would have loved to see a Queen on the flop and bust his sorry ass, but the right play was fold.
A couple hands later, the young gun raises from the big blind. I was not in the hand, but it felt like he was trying to weed out the limpers.
Afterall, 8 players limped in.
Having that many players in the hand by limping is not poker to me. It is bingo.
The flop was A-4-2 rainbow.
The kid checks.
Mr. Player from seat 1 bets hard.
The kid comes over the top.
I put him on a straight.
Mr. Player played back at the kid all the way to the river.
The kid shows 5-3 for a straight.
Mr. Player shows A-K for top pair.
Then, he lost it.
“You are reckless!” the guy in seat 1 says.
“Reckless?” the kid responds.
Seat 1 goes on this speech about raising with 5-3 and so on.
This kid clammed up. Nobody had ever yelled at him. I really thought he was going to cry.
Well, we were not going to have any of that. There is no crying in poker.
Not at the table anyway. What happens in your car on the way home from a bad session, stays in your car.
I digress.
Compelled to help defend the kid, I explain that he was making a play at the pot to get the weak players out.
Sure, the kid got lucky by flopping a straight. But, a real player would have folded A-K with a straight out there.
Then, I criticize seat 1 for over-playing A-K.
This put him on tilt. He donked off all his chips by the end of the next round.
The hand he went out on? Ace-King.






